Home Insurance After Paying Off Mortgage

House on money, mortgage or property real estate tax

May 9, 2025 | Property Insurance

Once you’ve paid off your mortgage, it feels like a huge weight has been lifted. But while you no longer have a lender to answer to, there are still important steps to take to protect your home. Just because you’ve finished paying off your home loan doesn’t mean you can skip home insurance after paying off your mortgage. Many homeowners make the mistake of thinking insurance is only necessary while they’re still paying off the loan, but that’s far from the truth. 

Your home is still your biggest investment, and it’s crucial to keep it protected from unexpected events like fires, storms, or break-ins. Even without a lender requiring it, home insurance provides peace of mind, ensuring that your home—and everything in it—remains safe. Let’s take a look at why it’s still important to keep that coverage, even after you’ve paid off your mortgage.

Why You Still Need Home Insurance

Just because the bank no longer requires home insurance doesn’t mean you should drop it. Your home is still at risk, and now it’s all on you to protect it. Fires, storms, theft, and other damage can happen anytime—insurance helps cover the cost to fix or replace what’s lost.

Think about how much you’ve put into your home over the years. You’ve worked hard to pay it off, and now it’s one of your biggest investments. Home insurance after paying off your mortgage gives you peace of mind. If something goes wrong, you won’t be stuck paying out of pocket for major repairs.

Even though it’s not required by law, keeping your coverage is one of the smartest things you can do. You’ve come this far—protect what’s yours.

What Changes When the Mortgage is Gone

Once you’ve paid off your mortgage, a few things change with your home insurance. First, no lender is telling you what to do. That means you’re not required to carry insurance, but it’s still a good idea to keep it.

The good news? You now get to choose your own policy and provider without anyone else’s say. You can shop around for better coverage, better prices, or both. You’re in control now.

Also, if you were paying your premium through an escrow account, that stops. You’ll need to pay your home insurance bill directly, either once a year or in smaller monthly payments—whatever works best for your budget.

This is a great time to take a fresh look at your policy and make sure it fits your needs. Home insurance after paying off your mortgage should still give you the protection you want, just with a little more freedom.

How to Update Your Insurance Policy

Now that your mortgage is paid off, it’s time to update your home insurance policy. Here’s how to make sure everything’s up to date:

Remove the Mortgage Lender from Your Policy

Since you no longer owe money to a lender, they should no longer be listed on your policy. Contact your insurance provider to remove them and make sure your coverage reflects that change.

Review and Update Your Coverage Amounts

You’ve likely made improvements to your home over the years, and the value of your property may have changed. Take a look at your coverage limits and adjust them if needed to make sure your home is fully protected in case of damage or loss.

Consider Adding Extra Coverage

Now’s a good time to think about adding things like flood insurance or umbrella coverage. These add-ons offer extra protection in case something unexpected happens. It’s better to have it and not need it than need it and not have it.

Updating your policy after paying off your mortgage ensures that your coverage is still doing the job it needs to. It helps protect your home for years to come.

Can You Cancel Your Insurance? (And Why You Shouldn’t)

Yes, technically, you can cancel your home insurance after paying off your mortgage—but it’s not a move you want to make lightly.

Without insurance, you’re putting yourself at serious financial risk. If something were to happen—like a fire, storm, or break-in—you’d be stuck paying for repairs or replacements out of your own pocket. That could end up costing a lot more than your insurance premium.

Home insurance is your safety net. Even though the bank is no longer involved, you’re still the one responsible for your home. Keeping your insurance coverage ensures you’re protected, no matter what happens. It’s one of the best ways to safeguard the investment you’ve worked so hard for.

So, while canceling might seem tempting, sticking with your policy is a much smarter move in the long run.

Ways to Save on Premiums Now That You’re in Control

Now that you’re in control of your home insurance, it’s a great time to find ways to save on premiums. Here are some simple tips to help you lower your costs:

Shop Around for Better Rates or Bundle with Auto

Just because you’ve had the same insurance provider doesn’t mean it’s the best deal anymore. Take a few minutes to compare rates with other companies. If you have car insurance, you might be able to save by bundling both home and auto insurance.

Raise Your Deductible to Lower Premiums

If you’re comfortable with a higher out-of-pocket cost in case of a claim, raising your deductible can lower your monthly premium. Just be sure to choose a deductible you can afford to pay if something happens.

Look for Discounts

Many insurance companies offer discounts you might not know about. Check for things like loyalty discounts (being with the same insurer for a while), security discounts, or having no claims history. Every little bit helps!

By taking control and exploring these options, you can make sure you’re getting the best coverage at the best price.

Still Need Home Insurance? Why It’s Worth Keeping

In the end, keeping your home insurance after paying off your mortgage is a smart choice. While you’re no longer required by the bank, your home is still your biggest investment. It’s important to protect it from unexpected damage or loss. Home insurance gives you peace of mind, knowing that you won’t be left to cover expensive repairs on your own.

After paying off your mortgage, you’re in control, and you have the freedom to adjust your coverage as needed. It’s all about protecting what you’ve worked so hard to own and ensuring that your home remains safe, no matter what happens.

If you’re unsure about your current coverage or want to explore your options, it’s helpful to speak with an insurance agent. They can provide a custom review and help you find the best policy for your needs.

Related Posts

How Much Should You Insure Your Home For?

How Much Should You Insure Your Home For?

Your home is one of the biggest investments you'll ever make, so protecting it with the right insurance coverage just makes sense. But how much should you insure your home for? That’s a question many homeowners aren’t sure how to answer. Too little coverage could...

Flood Protection: Keep Yourself Safe This Flood Season

Flood Protection: Keep Yourself Safe This Flood Season

Floodwaters don’t knock—they barge in, leaving destruction in their wake. Every year, torrential rains, overflowing rivers, and storm surges threaten homes, businesses, and entire communities. The devastating reality? Most people underestimate the risk until it's too...

Why Private Flood Insurance is Better Than FEMA

Why Private Flood Insurance is Better Than FEMA

Flooding is a big problem in Houston, Texas. Heavy rain and hurricanes can cause water to rise fast, putting homes and businesses in danger. Many people think government flood insurance will protect them, but that is not always true. You may not have enough coverage...

How can we help?

When it comes to finding insurance, Dickey Insurance stands as your reliable and trusted broker. We understand that everyone’s insurance needs are unique, which is why we provide personalized coverage options. Connect with one of our dependable agents for a quote.

Get Quote